There are several services now set up to bring advocates into your organization on a cost-per-acquisition basis. Care2, Change.org, and CQ Roll Call are the main ones that have come across my desk.
In full disclosure, I have not yet tried these services. I hope that anyone who has can tell about their experience in the comments (or contact me at email@example.com; I’d love to set up a guest blog opportunity to help correct my vast areas of ignorance).
But I do know what would be required for me to participate in these types of campaigns:
- Maximizing free/content marketing efforts
- Optimized advocacy forms and efforts
- Strong knowledge of the value of each advocate and a strong projection of the value of these externally acquired advocates versus internally acquired ones.
I’ll go through each of these in turn, as these would be valuable whether or not you decide to invest in cost-per-acquisition campaigns.
Maximizing free/content marketing efforts
Speaking of, after donation forms, advocacy activities are the best thing you can direct search traffic to, as they convert very well. It’s usually a safe bet that the person searching for “email congress seal clubbing” wants to email their elected officials about seal clubbing. And if they click through on your ad, they are probably on the con side.
(A note: as of this writing, there are no nonprofit ads for the term “seal clubbing,” but Humane Society and PETA are on the first page of search results. Opportunity?)
That’s on the search engine side, but the more important part is to make advocacy a part of your communications. The more you talk about activities and activations in your blog, enewsletter, social media, and Web site, the more people will interact with it. Here are some potential topics:
- Highlight news stories about your issue.
- And don’t just retweet that article about your issue; add the note that that’s why we have to pass HB1489 (or whatever) with a link for people to take action.
- Blog a first-person account from one of your volunteers who lobbied legislators and how rewarding it was.
- Talk about your lobby day (state or national) and invite your constituents to be a part of a virtual lobby day online.
- Honor legislators who have been champions of your cause.
- Tell success stories of passed legislation (since you should be doing these for your online and offline petition signers anyway).
- Post a legislative agenda for the year and report back on it with the legislature(s) is/are closed.
Hopefully, these will increase interests in your petitions or emails to legislators.
Optimize advocacy forms and efforts. I probably should have mentioned earlier that you need a platform for emailing legislators that allows you to own the constituent, not whatever petition service you are working. These can range from setting up your own form on your site to ones that come with your CRM to paid solutions of all stripes. If there’s enough interest (you can let me know by emailing me at firstname.lastname@example.org), I can review these solutions in a future post. For now, suffice it to say that the value in advocacy online is to whom the constituent belongs. If it’s you, you can ask for future actions — advocacy and otherwise; if it’s someone else, you are helping them build their house, not yours.
Once you have these forms, it’s important that you treat your advocacy form like a donation form (if possible), where you are continually testing and refining your system. For example, if you are doing a national petition, you may just ask for name and email address in order to maximize form completion. I would advocate also asking for zip code; if you are going to be asking people to participate in other advocacy efforts, you will have to know in which districts they fall. That may be it in order to get people into your organization. Physical address may impair your form activation rates to the point that it is more profitable (side note: we need a term for profitable, but for non-profits; non-profitable sounds like the opposite of what it is) to leave that off and either ask for or append (or, more likely, both) the data afterward.
Further, there are all the usual things to test:
- Does your petition work better at left or right?
- Pictures on the page or spartan?
- One-step action or multi-step?
- How much copy to sell the petition action?
- And so on
You definitely want this tested before trying any sort of paid campaign so you are not pouring water into a bucket without a bottom.
You also want to put similar rigor behind what communications you send advocates after their advocacy. This would include a customized advocate welcome series, what (if any) is the first mailing they would get, what other actions you ask them to take, etc. More on this tomorrow.
These are significant determinants of lifetime value, so you want these well in place before…
Determining the value of an advocate
For some organizations, having an advocate is its own reward. For most, however, it’s also an activity on which you will want to break at least even. Unfortunately, lifetime value is hard and multichannel attribution is its own week of blog posts at some point. So here’s a quick and dirty hack for figuring out how much you should be willing to invest to get an advocate:
- Pull a list of everyone who came into your online database via advocacy action.
- Pull a list of the donations these people made online over the past year.
- Average the sum of the donations by the number of people in your database via advocacy action to find the one year value of an advocate.
I can hear purists out there screaming at me: “what about future year revenues from an advocate?”, “what about the value these constituents have in recruiting other constituents?”, “what about the gifts made in other channels?”, etc.
I agree: this is not the best way to pull an average advocate’s lifetime value. It is, however, a quick one. And it sets a baseline: if you know the average advocate is going to pay for themselves in 12 months, all of their other activities will be gravy.
That is, if you work this equation and it says the average advocate on your file gave you $3 last year, you know that acquiring an advocate for up to three dollars is valuable. If your advocacy page converts at 10%, you know that you can put up CPC ads on search networks and pay up to $.30 per click. You can experiment with online petition sites, which charge at least $1.50 per advocate (in my experience). And you can value your online communications that bring in new advocates versus those that bring in new donors.
So this dart throw, primitive though it may be, can help you determine your communications mix and investment. Not back for something you can do in Excel in 15 minutes.
If you would like more tips like this one, please sign up for our weekly newsletter. There you will get to pick new topics for the blog, see related content to what you get on Direct to Donor, and get a TL;DR version of the week’s news. Thanks!